Last month, a friend of mine set up a men’s group at Oxford University. With a view to encouraging men to explore what it means to be a man in the world today, carving out their own path whilst getting support from other men wanting to explore the same, Alex took a stand for there being more powerful loving men in the world.
The only thing was, there was rather a large shitstorm created in its wake. What was most interesting was that there were TWO camps of opposition to the idea of there being a mens-only group: The feminists…and the chauvanists. Loaded Editor Martin Daubney came out, calling it “navel-gazing”, alluding that men should just “get on with it”. What happened next was a melodrama of attacks from both camps, followed by a great article in support of such groups from Guardian Editor, Jenny Agg.
Even as he was being attacked, Alex stood strong on 3 radio stations, and even on BBC TV. A lot of less mature commentators reverted to personal insults, spreading lies, and resorting to huge reactionary tactics. Lots of women in the feminist camp were coming out saying it inhibited their own expression as women in the world. Lots of men, in reaction, came out in attack of feminism as trying to slowly subjugate men into the oppression they have enacted upon women for the last few millenia. Where would you stand in such a debate? Let me say, I can see points in both arguments.
Rather than “sit on the fence”, this is where I choose to stand:
The Conversation That Exists
There is a story, rooted in deep wounds of the past, that says that men have inhibited the free speech of women for longer than we can remember. So as our society evolves, women are now finding their voices. They are in more positions of power. They are in more areas of our society. In history, the women’s story stops there. The men’s story begins here: As men, we are finding that more and more second-class attitudes toward men. We find ourselves performing poorly in school. We find ourselves trapped in a health & safety nightmare where we are being taught to “be useful rather than be purposeful…and safe”. As more women find their power, something has entered our own psyche which says that we are not allowed to be powerful.
Power for men has often been equated with aggression, abuse, and arrogance. These are traits so quickly attributed to men. Let’s face it guys, we’ve earned the right to these traits. There is a lot of history backing this up. And yet, can we apologize for this? Most of us were not around back then. What most hardliners don’t realize is that we have allowed ourselves to be defined by the social reality of the past. This is nobody’s fault. There is no one to “blame”. Even if we can find someone, we will never get them over to realise that there is another way possible for us to move forward. Today there is another way we can go. We have an opportunity: We take responsibility for who we are TODAY!
If we are to have true equality in our society, there are things we must achieve.
- Men AND women must have an outlet to discuss what is going on for them.
- Men and women must recognize that they are equal, but not necessarily the same.
I get persistently bored of seeing some trying to harmonize the sexes by trying to say “we’re all the same”. Well yeah, sure, in some ways we are. But then, there are so many ways that we’re different. But we’ve collapsed “different” with “equal”. We think that if we say we’re different, it means somehow that one is better than the other! Please, let it go, it’ll be better if you just get over that we’re different and learn to actually celebrate our differences. WHY? Because let’s face it everyone, it’s simply boring!
As a man, I’ve recognized that when I’m around strong men, I feel stronger. Those guys who just exude trust from every pore of their being. Those guys who you just look at and know you could rely on them. I get the same feeling from strong women, although it is a different feeling.
What if we could grow men like this? What if we could remove the “gender studies” focus when we talk about men and women, and learn to realize that there are times that women can benefit from being around other women, and men benefit from being around other men. I’m not arguing for a segregated society. I’m not arguing for an imposed order. It’s an invitation.
Try it out!
We all have male and female friends thesedays. What does it feel like to be around your own gender? Are you ready for exploring what it means to be a powerful, loving, courageous man with other men?
Healthy Masculinity, Healthy Femininity
In this country today, we are all looking for courageous leadership that listens to all parties but can stand strong in leading us into the future. But in Britain, we have decided it’s best to remain on the fence. And it’s killing both men and women. We’ve learned to put up with a patriarchal society by attacking HEALTHY forms of masculinity, leaving the unhealthy forms running our country!
We don’t encourage ANY masculinity. Nor do we encourage ANY femininity. The cost? Women never get to learn how powerful they are. Men never get to learn they can be powerful. The most open-hearted loving men in our society often don’t get to power. They were never caused to be powerful by being supported by other strong men around them who wouldn’t let them sacrifice ANY of their values! There are millions of people out there who are just waiting for the day when they’ll be happy! They’re waiting to make a difference!
FOR Women, FOR Men
I sometimes find myself reacting to the term “feminism”. Not because I’m against women. But because I’m much more interested in Celebration of both sexes, where neither sex is left behind. It will surely be much messier. But unless we inform people of healthier forms of masculinity, we’ll have more boys looking for that juicy flavour of masculinity through crime and violence. They’ll never get taught healthy male sexuality, instead turning to the objectification of women.
Really, this is not a good idea! Trust me! You can’t kill this thirst for something emboldening in men. You can only direct it. You do not want to ignore it…
For all the outpouring of support Alex has received, this has really emboldened us all to believe that there ARE people out there really wanting something richer, deeper and more fulfilling in their lives! Both the men and the women who have supported him know there is something missing.
Current State of Men’s Groups in the UK
I know there are men’s groups in the UK (I used to be in one). So when I did a google search for “mens groups uk”, I was immediately hit by the UK Men’s Movement. What I saw I did not really expect…but was not really surprised.
Have you ever seen one of them 9/11 truth websites where they say how much we’re all being lied to an manipulated? Where their websites are filled with angry, frustration and hatred? That’s what I found when I clicked.
This group were upset at feeling like they were being victimized by the feminists in this country. I’m sure they have a lot of evidence to back up their claims. I’m sure they could prove pretty well, and get a lot of agreement on it, that men were being discriminated against in a subtle way from women in the world. I was instantly turned off…
Look guys, nobody likes a victim. Nobody likes listening to a victim. I’m not saying you don’t have a point. I’m just saying, let’s give it up! It’s just an invitation I’m making! Give up believing you are a victim and recognize there is still a lot of work to do. Remember Gandhi’s iconic line “BE the change you want to be in the world!”. I invite you to BE the men you want to be in the world! I invite you to give up being this way.
BE The Man You Want To Be
The world needs to see that we can have strong, loving men who actually give a damn! They need to see that men deserve as much a part in the future of our planet as women do. If someone says men should not be allowed as much power as women, let me invite you to do something. Let them have that!
Are you going to change their minds? Probably not.
Are you going to get them to look at you with the respect you are wanting? No, again, probably not.
Do you really want to cry about this? You may do. Sometimes I do when I come across people like this. Do I want to let myself stay in crying about it? Does that really empower me to have them see me any differently? If we want to make a difference in the world today, nobody will listen to someone who continually pouts how much they are under attack!
Be the man you want to be! And let whoever doesn’t believe in what you are fighting for believe what they want to believe!
Want to start a Mens group? Check out this podcast first…it’s a great place to start!